csQCA Analysis

Crisp-set QCA of the 44 relevant cases among the 49 FM vendors in the population at 2026-09-30, outcome the viability of the business model (base rate 0.818). Generated by research/census-final/qca/run.R; this is the case census, not the OpenRouter model catalogue.

N=44
36 viable · 8 non-viable
17/64
Configurations observed
~PAID 0.917
Necessary for viability
0.941 / 0.889
Solution cons. / cov.
1/5
Propositions supported
64/70
~PAID necessary in variants

Sufficiency: what is sufficient for viability

MONOPOLY • INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL + INTEGRATED • PAID • HIERARCHICAL + INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN + WIDE • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL + ~INTEGRATED • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL • OPEN + ~WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN → VIABLE
consistency 0.941 · coverage 0.889 · 32 of 36 cases covered · not covered: AI21 Labs, Black Forest Labs, Inception and Recraft
TermCons.Raw cov.Cases
MONOPOLY • INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL1.0000.194Alibaba/Qwen, Amazon, Baidu, Google, Meta, Microsoft and Tencent
INTEGRATED • PAID • HIERARCHICAL1.0000.028IBM
INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN1.0000.222Amazon, Baidu, ByteDance, Google, Kwai, Meta, Microsoft and xAI
WIDE • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL1.0000.500Alibaba/Qwen, Amazon, Anthropic, ByteDance, Cohere, DeepSeek, Dots Studio (rednote hi lab), Google, Meituan, Meta, MiniMax, Mistral AI, Moonshotai, OpenAI, Reka, StepFun, xAI and Xiaomi
~INTEGRATED • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL • OPEN0.8670.361ArceeAI, Cohere, Dots Studio (rednote hi lab), InclusionAI (Ant Group), Liquid, MiniMax, Moonshotai, Nvidia, Poolside, Stability AI, Xiaomi, z.ai and Zyphra · against: Adept AI and Databricks
~WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN1.0000.028Aleph Alpha
2 equally minimal models; the terms above are those of model 1.
M1: MONOPOLY • INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL + INTEGRATED • PAID • HIERARCHICAL + INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN + WIDE • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL + ~INTEGRATED • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL • OPEN + ~WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN
M2: INTEGRATED • PAID • HIERARCHICAL + INTEGRATED • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN + WIDE • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL + MONOPOLY • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL • OPEN + ~INTEGRATED • ~PAID • HIERARCHICAL • OPEN + ~WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN
Parsimonious: INTEGRATED + WIDE • ~PAID + ~PAID • OPEN + ~WIDE • PAID • ~OPEN

Intermediate solution, computed with the directional expectations of the propositions. In 71 robustness variants the solution is the same in 11, the same with a different fit in 28, and changes in 32.

No configuration is sufficient for death

~MONOPOLY • ~WIDE • ~HIERARCHICAL • OPEN + ~MONOPOLY • WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN → ~VIABLE
consistency 1.000 · coverage 0.250 · 2 of 8 cases covered · not covered: 01.AI/Yi, Adept AI, Databricks, Inflection AI, Snowflake and Together AI
TermCons.Raw cov.Cases
~MONOPOLY • ~WIDE • ~HIERARCHICAL • OPEN1.0000.125Recursal AI / Featherless AI
~MONOPOLY • WIDE • PAID • HIERARCHICAL • ~OPEN1.0000.125Writer
Parsimonious: ~HIERARCHICAL + WIDE • PAID

Minimised separately, on its own truth table. With 8 non-viable cases it describes where the deaths sit and supports no general claim.

Necessity: ~PAID is necessary for viability

ConditionCons. (Y=1)Cov. (Y=1)RoNVerdict
MONOPOLY0.2781.0001.000—
~MONOPOLY0.7220.7650.556—
INTEGRATED0.3611.0001.000—
~INTEGRATED0.6390.7420.619—
WIDE0.5000.9470.962—
~WIDE0.5000.7200.731—
PAID0.0830.4290.902—
~PAID0.9170.8920.636necessary
HIERARCHICAL1.0000.8370.125trivially necessary
~HIERARCHICAL0.0000.0000.977—
OPEN0.5280.7920.800—
~OPEN0.4720.8500.889—

Threshold 0.90. 33 of the 36 viable vendors hold ~PAID: free access or payment in data. It stays necessary in 64 of the 70 robustness variants that analyse PAID. HIERARCHICAL passes but is trivially necessary. No condition is necessary for non-viability.

Propositions: P3 supported, P1, P2, P4 and P5 contradicted

PropositionStatementnCons.Verdict
P1 The generative routeOPEN • ~INTEGRATED • PAID → VIABLE40.250contradicted · same in 71/71 variants
P2 The orchestrated route~OPEN • ~INTEGRATED → VIABLE120.750contradicted · same in 65/71 variants
P3 Substitution by an adjacent monopolyMONOPOLY → VIABLE101.000supported · same in 71/71 variants
P4 Closure without a substitute~OPEN • INTEGRATED • ~MONOPOLY → ~VIABLE30.000contradicted · same in 70/71 variants
P5 Generativity without appropriationOPEN • ~PAID • ~MONOPOLY → ~VIABLE170.118contradicted · same in 69/71 variants
open Withheld configuration (open finding)OPEN • INTEGRATED • PAID • ~MONOPOLY → VIABLE11.000open finding

Each proposition is fitted as written, before the minimisation; consistency is read against the cut-off of 0.80 and the base rate of 0.818.

Truth table (17 observed rows)

ConfigConditionsnYVendors
000010†
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
5C
Black Forest LabsInceptionRecraft01.AI/Yi (Y=0)Inflection AI (Y=0)
000011†
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
101
ArceeAIInclusionAI (Ant Group)LiquidNvidiaPoolsideStability AIz.aiZyphraAdept AI (Y=0)Databricks (Y=0)
000101
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
10
Recursal AI / Featherless AI (Y=0)
000110
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
11
Aleph Alpha
000111†
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
3C
AI21 LabsSnowflake (Y=0)Together AI (Y=0)
001010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
21
RekaStepFun
001011
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
51
CohereDots Studio (rednote hi lab)MiniMaxMoonshotaiXiaomi
001110
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
10
Writer (Y=0)
010010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
11
Kwai
010111
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
11
IBM
011010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
21
ByteDancexAI
011011
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
21
DeepSeekMistral AI
101010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
31
AnthropicMeituanOpenAI
110010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
21
BaiduMicrosoft
110011
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
11
Tencent
111010
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
31
AmazonGoogleMeta
111011
MONINTWIDEPAIDHIEROPEN
11
Alibaba/Qwen
Config = M I W P H O; Y = VIABLE. † contradictory row: viable and non-viable vendors share the configuration. No majority rule: a row is assigned an outcome at a consistency of at least 0.80; below it both ways (C) it is an unresolved contradiction and enters neither minimisation. N=44 relevant cases across 17 observed configurations of 64 logically possible.

Configuration matrix (UpSet-style)

Top bars: cases per observed configuration. Row bars: how many of the 44 cases have each condition. Filled circles = condition present.

510113251112232131000010†000011†000101000110000111†00101000101100111001001001011101101001101110101011001011001111101011101110MON13INT19WIDE7PAID43HIER24OPENY=1Y=0† contradictory (assigned at the consistency cut-off, otherwise not minimised)

Karnaugh map (6 conditions, 64 cells)

Columns: M/I/W, rows: P/H/O (Gray-code order). 17 of the 64 cells are observed. Each cell shows n and viable:non-viable.

M I W →
P H O ↓
000
001
011
010
110
111
101
100
000
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
001
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
011
n=108:2
n=55:0
n=22:0
—
n=11:0
n=11:0
—
—
010
n=53:2
n=22:0
n=22:0
n=11:0
n=22:0
n=33:0
n=33:0
—
110
n=11:0
n=10:1
—
—
—
—
—
—
111
n=31:2
—
—
n=11:0
—
—
—
—
101
n=10:1
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
100
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
all viable
all non-viable
mixed (viable:non-viable)
unobserved

PEMAK triangle — vendor positions

Descriptive. Barycentric coordinates: Matching=(MON+INT)/2, Assembling=(WIDE+PAID)/2, Knowledge=(HIER+OPEN)/2; colour = viability status.

Matching(MON + INT)Assembling(WIDE + PAID)Knowledge(HIER + OPEN)ViableNon-viableNot a relevant case