Revisions
v7.3-r3latestComplete revision history, v5.0 (October 16, 2025) through v7.3-r3 (October 9, 2026) — monograph, paper, article, conference and dissertation editions. Every entry is transcribed from a changelog or an archived build in revisions/.
In preparation — the final v7.3 (October 2026)
Not built yet. The final release of the monograph after the pre-defense, on the data and results of v7.3-r3 below.
The final release of the monograph after the pre-defense, on the same data and results as v7.3-r3.
- fixConsistency read across the chapters, which also decides the length of the appendices
- fixCitation audit: the core method books checked against the texts
- methodThe critique, and the author’s rulings on 19 data points
source: model-of-models#126; revisions/rev-v7.3/CHANGELOG-v7.3.md
Work in progress — in no edition
The monograph is the lead edition: v7.3-r3 (October 9, 2026) is the last shipped revision, and the paper, article and dissertation editions are frozen at v7.0. The three research streams written since April are in no edition and claim no findings; Section 7.4 of the monograph names accordivity as a direction for future research. Rev-v7.1 and accordivity-v8.0 remain incompatible plans for Essay 3.
- Essay 3 construct enrichment (v7.1)April 4–5, 2026
research/rev-v7.1/Enriches Essay 3 with the Probabilistic Gap, Cognitary, AINE and Post-Neo Institutional Economics constructs, keeping and deepening the DSR / incomplete-contracting framing. 14 HIGH-priority changes are specified; 12 TikZ diagrams are specified and none is built.
revision brief ready · not implemented · in no edition - Accordivity as platform ecosystem strategy (v8.0)May 22, 2026
research/accordivity-v8.0/Rewrites the same eleven Essay 3 files as a theory-building multi-case study (Eisenhardt, 1989): seven case clusters and a four-dimension coding matrix (TC/RO/IH/AA). Drops the DSR / incomplete-contracting framing and demotes the GABMS specification to an appendix. Case D2 (Anthropic/Claude) is still coded TBD.
active prototype · not implemented · incompatible with v7.1 · in no edition - The Reasoning Economy — PEMAK-RJune 11, 2026
research/reasoning-economy/Recasts Brousseau & Pénard’s Knowledge Management pillar as Reasoning, deriving nine trade-offs (TR1–TR9) of which six are new. Verdict: domain-stratified supersession, roughly 14:1 augmentation-to-supersession across 18 incumbents — a new function, not a wholesale replacement. Its brief names two destinations at once, a standalone paper and input to the dissertation general introduction, and does not choose between them.
research package complete · in no edition
research/INDEX.md is the ledger for all three streams; the v7.3 round is epic #98 in the project repository. None of the three streams touches the QCA. The April N=49 census is replaced by the final census in research/census-final/ (49 vendors, N=44).
Shipped editions
The analysis and the preliminary findings — 528 pages, every chapter written. Best effort for the pre-defense of 16–17 October 2026; the final v7.3 follows it.
- dataN=44 relevant cases: 36 viable, 8 non-viable; base rate 0.818
- dataNecessity: ~PAID is necessary for viability (consistency 0.917, coverage 0.892); no other non-trivial necessary condition
- dataSufficiency, intermediate solution for VIABLE: consistency 0.941, coverage 0.889, 2 equally minimal models. For non-viability: consistency 1.000, coverage 0.250
- theoryPropositions: P3 (substitution by an adjacent monopoly) supported; P1, P2, P4 and P5 contradicted
- methodRobustness: 73 variants fixed in advance, 71 computed; ~PAID necessary in 64 of the 70 variants in which PAID is analysed
- newChapters 4–7 and Appendices A–F written; abstract and Chapter 1 revised with the results; one prose pass over every chapter
- newPre-defense deck: conference/v7.3-predefense/ (23 main and 7 backup slides)
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.3/jxu-mom-20261009-v7.3-r3.pdf — 528 pages
source: revisions/rev-v7.3/CHANGELOG-v7.3.md
The research design stated in full, results pending — 220 pages.
- methodChapter 3, sections 3.3–3.7 complete: population and relevant cases, outcome rule, calibration, coding protocol, analytical procedure
- newAbstract and Chapter 1 interim: the signed-off design, five propositions, six conditions; no finding
- dataSix conditions coded for all 49 vendors from dated evidence, two passes then adjudication; descriptive engagement indicators for the 44 relevant cases
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.3/jxu-mom-20261004-v7.3-r2.pdf — 220 pages
source: revisions/rev-v7.3/CHANGELOG-v7.3.md
First tagged revision of v7.3: the design signed off, Chapter 2 complete — 156 pages.
- theoryChapter 2 complete (about 85 pages): literature review, analytical framework, propositions P1–P5
- methodOutcome redefined as the viability of the business model, observed through its death; the six PEMAK trade-offs as the only conditions; no expert panel and no fuzzy-set analysis claimed
- dataCensus rebuilt from the full archived record, 2023-06-29 to 2026-09-30: 138 author slugs, 131 organisations, 49 foundation model vendors under one population rule
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.3/jxu-mom-20261004-v7.3-r1.pdf — 156 pages
source: revisions/rev-v7.3/CHANGELOG-v7.3.md
The re-analysis on the census-q3-2026 list (41 vendors in the population) — 264 pages. Superseded by v7.3, which rebuilt the census and the design.
- dataCensus at the 2026-09-30 cutoff from the cutoff-day catalogue: 53 candidates, 41 in the population; 35 survive, 2 exit, 4 unresolved
- methodcsQCA run by script (run.R → results.json); the v7.0 reproduction gives 216 of 244 reported numbers; expert panel and fsQCA check withdrawn for lack of records
- fixNo condition necessary; survival solution ~PAID + OPEN (0.971 / 0.971), not robust; ~MONOPOLY • INTEGRATED holds 7 surviving vendors
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.2/jxu-mom-20261004-v7.2.pdf — 264 pages
source: revisions/rev-v7.2/CHANGELOG-v7.2.md
First complete build of the 3-essay thèse par articles for Paris Dauphine-PSL — 328 pages. Frozen at this state: no dissertation prose has changed since.
- newGeneral Introduction and General Conclusion written: three research questions, the three-essay architecture, the connecting thread
- newFront matter to institutional format — English abstract, French résumé (required by Paris Dauphine-PSL), acknowledgements
- theoryEssay 1 — Foundation Models as Digital Platforms (~85 pp): PEMAK functional equivalence; six binary conditions; complementor engagement as the viability threshold
- dataEssay 2 — Configurational Viability (~120 pp): the N=49 csQCA carried over unchanged; two equifinal paths, Death Zone structurally absent, OPEN sufficient 20/20
- theoryEssay 3 — Accordivity (~90 pp): 9-stage institutional-economics genealogy, Contributivity, the Accordivity Stack, propositions P1–P4, GABMS specification
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.0-de/jxu-mom-20260403-v7.0-de.pdf — 328 pages, zero build errors
source: revisions/rev-v7.0-de/CHANGELOG-v7.0-de.md
A 27-page conference-format cut of the configurational analysis. No changelog was written for this build — this entry is read off the archived PDF.
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.0/jxu-mom-20260401-v7.0-ce.pdf — 27 pages, single-column conference template
- fixNo changelog accompanies this edition; the site reports only what the artifact itself shows
source: revisions/rev-v7.0/jxu-mom-20260401-v7.0-ce.pdf (no changelog written)
Cross-format synchronisation: the monograph and paper editions re-cut from the article baseline.
- fixMonograph methodology and data chapters migrated to vendor-level framing (N=49; 44 Y=1, 5 Y=0)
- methodNew §3.3.5 longitudinal validation (Wayback archive) added and wired into monograph/pdf.yaml
- fixChapter 5 normalised away from legacy "atomic" language and stale metadata; Chapters 6–7 harmonised to the Q1 2026 baseline
- fixRegional Platform Incumbent recipe made consistent across discussion and conclusion: INTEGRATED · HIERARCHICAL · ~MONOPOLY
- pePaper edition front matter re-stamped to v7.0-PE, dated 2026-03-30
- buildArchived: jxu-mom-20260330-v7.0.pdf (328 pp, monograph) and jxu-mom-20260330-v7.0-pe.pdf (106 pp, paper edition)
source: revisions/rev-v7.0/CHANGELOG-v7.0.md, CHANGELOG-v7.0-pe.md
Data model clarification: 109 OpenRouter authors are not 49 FM vendors. Additive only — no QCA result changed.
- methodExplicit FM-vendor definition in §3.2 and in the TypeScript interfaces: trains base weights + releases commercially + deploys via API
- dataSchema: vendors.category (FM/FT/IP/RL/ED) and vendor_qca_mapping.v70_verdict (IN/CANDIDATE/EXCLUDE)
- fix8 phantom slug mappings corrected — z.ai, Moonshotai, Reka, StepFun, Kwai, IBM, ByteDance, Mistral AI; all 49 vendors now join to the models table
- methodOpenRouter's dual role documented: a case in the study (Y=1, T02) and the census instrument (109 authors via the Wayback archive)
- newInfrastructure: audit_vendors.py (HuggingFace verification) and scripts/verify_v70_consistency.sh, which now gates CI
- dataObservation window deliberately unchanged at Q1 2026 — v7.0 clarifies the data model, it does not re-date the census
- buildArchived as revisions/rev-v7.0/jxu-mom-20260330-v7.0-ae.pdf — 27 pages
source: revisions/rev-v7.0/CHANGELOG-v7.0-ae.md
Census finalized at N=49; z.ai consolidation; 12 new vendors; T14/T15 added; Collective/Proprietary Path labels fixed.
- dataCensus finalized: N=49 (44 Y=1 + 5 Y=0) — up from N=40
- newz.ai consolidation: Zhipu AI/GLM + Z-AI merged → z.ai (T06, API brand of Zhipu/THUDM)
- new12 new vendors added: Tencent, Meituan, IBM, AI21 Labs, Black Forest Labs, Kwai, Upstage, Reka, Writer, Stability AI, Xiaomi (+ Aleph Alpha as Y=0)
- newT14 new config: MONOPOLY·INTEGRATED·WIDE·PAID·HIERARCHICAL·OPEN → IBM (1 case)
- newT15 new config: ~MONOPOLY·~INTEGRATED·WIDE·PAID·HIERARCHICAL·OPEN → AI21/BFL/Kyutai/Xiaomi (4 cases)
- newAleph Alpha added as Y=0 (T04 deviant) — strategic pivot away from standalone FM API
- fix"Unbundled specialist" / "Platform aggregator" → "Collective Path" / "Proprietary Path" throughout web app and paper
- data~INTEGRATED: cons=0.919, cov=0.773, n=34; MONOPOLY·WIDE: cons=0.929, cov=0.295, n=13
- dataOPEN=1 → Y=1: 20/20 vendors (was 13/13); overall solution consistency 0.917 preserved
Complementor Engagement framework; N=40; Collective/Proprietary Path naming.
- theoryNew §2.4: Complementor Engagement (CE) theoretical framework — Active Orchestration vs. Ecosystem Generativity
- newCollective Path / Proprietary Path pathway naming throughout
- newAdept AI (T04) added as Y=0 — Amazon acqui-hire June 2024
- newZhipu AI/GLM + 01.AI/Yi added as Y=1 (Chinese open-weight vendors, T06)
- dataN=40 (was N=37); 37 Y=1 + 3 Y=0; overall consistency 0.917
- exclMosaicML excluded — vendor metamorphosis (not org death); MPT ecosystem continues under Databricks
- newChanson-Rocchi structural analogue: CE = API adoption threshold preceding FM viability
- newNet-new bibliography: iansiti2004, nambisan2017
N=34 data alignment, truth table corrections, Adept AI investigation.
- fixN=34 data alignment and truth table corrections across all paper files
- newAdept AI investigation initiated (Amazon acqui-hire evidence review)
- dataN=34; overall consistency 0.939
IOE theoretical grounding; §2.4 propositions; Death Zone formalized.
- theoryIOE theoretical grounding: Williamson (TCE), West/Spolsky (commoditize-your-complement)
- theory§2.4 Propositions P1a/P1b (Proprietary equifinality), P2a/P2b (open heterogeneity), P3 (structurally absent)
- newDeath Zone analysis formalized: ~MONOPOLY · INTEGRATED = empty set, n=0
- newIOE references: hart1995, west2006, spolsky2002, williamson1985, bottcher2022, weking2022
First paper edition: condensed from monograph for journal submission.
- peFirst paper edition (PE) derived from v6.5 monograph
- dataN=33 census (31 Y=1 + 2 Y=0)
- newCondensed to journal-length format; methodology chapter preserved
Research questions aligned to QCA findings; IOE governance pivot completed.
- fixResearch questions (§1.3) revised to map directly to QCA results and six tenets
- newNew question: "Missing Configuration" — why ~MONOPOLY·INTEGRATED is structurally absent
- methodqca_logic_mapping.md: master reference table linking all 6 logical steps across monograph
Overfull resolution; typography cleanup; introduction polished.
- fixZero overfull hbox warnings after systematic table and margin fixes
- fixIntroduction §1.1–§1.4 polished; "Institutional Gap" framing refined
Governance Pivot — IOE as second theoretical pillar.
- theoryNew §2.1.3: IOE lens — Transaction Cost Economics, Property Rights Theory, Agency Theory
- theoryChapter 6 reframed through Institutional Path Dependence and "Ideological Firewall" (US–China)
- newNew §6.5: archetypes as institutional governance forms with policy focus per configuration
- newChapter 7 expanded: Structural Separation, Tiered Licensing, Experimentalist Governance
Reference bugfix and formatting release.
- fixAppendix bibliography corrections; citation type mismatches resolved
- fixHeading level compliance: all L4 headings flattened per style guide
Appendix refactoring; QCA calibration evidence integrated.
- methodAppendix restructured: calibration evidence matrix with three-source triangulation
- newQCA calibration protocol for each of 6 conditions documented with secondary citations
Major methodology revision: constant condition resolved; 25 new citations.
- methodConstant condition problem resolved: HIERARCHICAL condition redefined with proper variance
- new~25 new peer-reviewed citations added across Chapters 2–4
- fixReference type corrections: 7 misclassified entries fixed (Evans2006, Radin2013, etc.)
Paris Dauphine-PSL institutional formatting; narrative polish.
- newTitle page updated to Université Paris Dauphine-PSL institutional format
- fixPEMAK framework positioning refined; economic dimension arguments sharpened
- fix"Titans vs. Champions" and market order narrative polished in Chapter 6
Major Chapter 4–5 restructuring; real data collection; population expanded.
- dataPrimary data collection phase: vendor census expanded with real market data
- methodChapter 4–5 restructured to separate data chapter from analysis chapter
- newPopulation of FM vendors expanded; inclusion/exclusion criteria formalized
Comprehensive methodology documentation; QCA literature review added.
- method§2.3 QCA Methodology Literature Review: Ragin (2008), Fiss (2011), Rihoux & Ragin (2009)
- methodComplete calibration protocol with secondary research citations for all conditions
- newTerminology refinement: condition names standardized to MONOPOLY/INTEGRATED/WIDE/PAID/HIERARCHICAL/OPEN
Atomic csQCA shift — from fuzzy-set to crisp-set methodology.
- methodFROM fsQCA (continuous 0.0–1.0 scores) TO csQCA (binary 0/1 membership)
- methodRationale: increased analytical transparency, reduced calibration subjectivity, simpler replication
- methodThree-source triangulation calibration protocol established
Initial monograph — first complete draft.
- newFirst complete monograph draft submitted
- newSix archetypes identified via QCA; PEMAK framework applied to FM vendors
- dataInitial census N≈30; fuzzy-set QCA analysis
A condensed view of the most recent editions is on the Changelog →